Philips annexation nixed
City council longs for planned zoning.
Published Tuesday, July 2, 2002

The entire Philips farm will remain in the county for at least a little while longer after the Columbia City Council last night unanimously rejected a request to annex 75 acres of the tract.

Jenna Isaacson photo
Mayor Darwin Hindman, left, and City Manager Ray Beck listen to city council members last night discuss the possible annexation of a portion of the Philips tract southeast of Columbia. Citing a lack of planned zoning, the council later rejected the request in a unanimous vote.
The request from the A. Perry Philips Family Partnership to annex the property, which lies just southeast of Blue Acres Mobile Home Park, called for retaining the multi-family zoning designation that the 75-acre tract has carried since 1973.

Craig Van Matre, attorney for the partnership, said his clients sought zoning equivalent with its county designation and with the city’s involuntary annexation plan.

The Philips farm is part of the southern area targeted for involuntary annexation in an Aug. 6 ballot issue. The involuntary annexation plan shows the 75-acre tract as multifamily, though it would have to go through the standard city zoning process if voters approve the ballot issue.

City council members expressed reservations about going against a policy resolution that calls for planned zoning in the Little Bonne Femme watershed, which includes the Philips tract. Others reasoned that without city utilities, such as sanitary sewer, the land won’t develop in the county.

"We have no choice but to believe this should be planned development," Mayor Darwin Hindman said, noting that the city has held other developers in the vicinity to the same standard.

John Clark, president of the North Central Columbia Neighborhood Association, suggested the council leave the land in the county because development without city sewers and other utilities would be improbable. He said the Philips family will eventually have to come back to the city before it can develop the land.

"Just leave it in the county," Clark said. "You have that control. Use it."

Jenna Isaacson photo
Alyce Turner of the Boone County Smart Growth Coalition speaks out against the proposed voluntary annexation of 75 acres of the Phillips tract. Like others, Turner cited concerns about the potential environmental ramifications of developing the tract.
Public Works Director Lowell Patterson said it would be "tough" for the Philips farm owners to get an on-site sewer permit from the Missouri Department of Natural Resources, especially because it is in a sensitive watershed.

Alyce Turner, representing the Boone County Smart Growth Coalition, delivered to the council a petition with 920 signatures calling for preservation and public acquisition of the Philips farm. Like other speakers, Turner urged the council to deny the request until a plan is created for the entire 515-acre tract.

Second Ward Councilman Chris Janku said a city purchase of the whole tract would be an "unlikely proposition" because it’s so large and would probably cost too much. He said the decision to deny the request goes back to the council’s resolution suggesting planned development.

"I don’t intend to go back on" the resolution "with this vote," he said, "as much as we’d like to have this in the city at this point."